Why diaries lie in one direction
When intake is compared with a stricter method, people more often underestimate food than overestimate it. The holes are almost always in what is dense and what is embarrassing.
What usually falls out
Oil, sauce, cheese, nuts, drinks, “I only tasted it,” food from a child’s plate, a restaurant. In studies the underestimate has been hundreds of kilocalories a day. So a person sincerely eats “1,200,” the weight holds, and metabolism is “broken.” More often the log is broken.
A photo of the plate lowers the shame of an empty line: you do not have to remember at night. It does not make the estimate a laboratory one. A caption with grams of the dense food narrows the range more than an argument about the kind of rice.
How to live with an imperfect log
The same error matters more than perfection. If you always forget oil, add a spoon to every hot meal where it was, and the week becomes comparable with itself. Changing the target while the log is systematically low treats the wrong number.
What this text draws on
- NIH NIDDK: Healthy Weight, Nutrition, and Physical Activity — deficit, maintenance, habits.
- CDC: Losing Weight — pace and behavior steps (not a medical protocol).
- Doubly labelled water studies — under-reporting calories in food records.
A short paraphrase of open guides and reviews (WHO, national recommendations, peer‑reviewed summaries). Not a quotation and not a treatment protocol.
Short answers
Is a diary useful if it lies?
Yes. A diary that is 80% honest already shows weekends, drinks, and oil. A zero diary shows nothing.