Lifting while the weight goes down
Muscle is part of expenditure and part of how you look at the same weight. In a deficit it is kept with training and protein, not with hunger.
What practice points to
Reviews of people lifting in a deficit often land near 1.6–2.2 g of protein per kilogram. Less protein and no lifting shift the loss toward muscle. ScanDish’s “more protein” style starts at 2 g per kg and shrinks the number only when it does not fit the calories.
Training does not have to be daily or heroic. Two to four short lifting sessions a week are already a different conversation from walking only. Walking is still useful on its own, as NEAT, and it does not replace a squat or a pull.
What not to expect
In a deep deficit, records usually stall. That is not a failure. The point of training while losing is not to lose strength. Gym calories are not added to the bot’s target a second time: the day factor already includes ordinary activity.
What this text draws on
- NIH NIDDK: Healthy Weight, Nutrition, and Physical Activity — deficit, maintenance, habits.
- CDC: Losing Weight — pace and behavior steps (not a medical protocol).
A short paraphrase of open guides and reviews (WHO, national recommendations, peer‑reviewed summaries). Not a quotation and not a treatment protocol.
Short answers
Cardio or weights?
To keep muscle: lifting and protein. Walking helps expenditure and the head. Neither cancels the other.