ScanDish
RU Open the bot

Home · Diets

Deficit, maintenance, and gain

Almost every diet aimed at weight works by one mechanism: a week of energy below expenditure, and weight goes down; the same, and it holds; above, and it goes up. The name of the plate changes comfort, not physics.

Counting · 8 min · read the caveats

Deficit, maintenance, and gain

Where the number comes from

Resting metabolism is estimated first, then multiplied by an ordinary day. That is TDEE, daily expenditure with life included, not training alone. ScanDish estimates rest with Mifflin–St Jeor and the multipliers 1.2, 1.375, 1.55, and 1.725. The formula and an example live in the counting section.

The goal then shifts the number. In the bot a gentle pace is minus 250 kcal when losing and plus 200 when gaining. The usual pace is minus 400 and plus 300. A noticeable pace is minus 550 and plus 450. Maintenance does not shift. This is a pace, not a moral score.

The floor under the target

When losing, if the math falls below 1,500 kcal for the male equation and below 1,200 for the female equation, the bot keeps the floor. That is an application guard, not a personal medical bottom. A clinician may set something else. For some people even this floor is a poor fit. A guide does not replace a visit.

This site does not teach eating under the floor on purpose “to go faster.” Faster often means muscle, a rebound, and the weight back.

Why the scale argues with the diary

Salt, carbohydrate, a cycle, training, and sleep move water by a kilogram or more with the same fat tissue. So you watch two weeks and an average weight, not Monday morning against Tuesday morning. In the bot, weight has its own button and shows up in the stats.

If two or three honest weeks in a deficit do not move the average, the cause is often unlogged spoons of oil, drinks, and weekends. Less often, the activity multiplier is too generous. A clinic is the rare next step when symptoms travel with the weight.

Gaining is a plan too

Gaining weight is not “control switched off.” A chaotic surplus does not become muscle only. In the bot the addition above expenditure is modest and stepped. Protein on the ordinary plate is a little higher while gaining. Sleep and training decide where the gain goes, not porridge alone.

What this text draws on

  • NIH NIDDK: Healthy Weight, Nutrition, and Physical Activity — deficit, maintenance, habits.
  • CDC: Losing Weight — pace and behavior steps (not a medical protocol).

A short paraphrase of open guides and reviews (WHO, national recommendations, peer‑reviewed summaries). Not a quotation and not a treatment protocol.

Short answers

How many kilograms a week is reasonable?

The bot’s usual pace, about 400 kcal, is very roughly 0.3 kg a week if the diary and expenditure agree. Water makes weeks noisy.

Can you eat under 1,200?

The bot will not set that target. A therapeutic reduction under common guides belongs only in a clinic.